FA Cup winners should get Champions League place

FA Cup winners should get Champions League place

It is no secret that new UEFA president Michel Platini is looking to revamp the current format of the Champions League. But is it a good idea?

Under the current format the English, Italian and Spanish clubs that finish in the top four of their respective league are rewarded with a place in the Champions League. But Platini’s new proposal would alter this slightly by rewarding the winner of each league’s premier domestic cup with the final Champions League place rather than the league’s fourth-place finisher. The idea behind his proposal is to put some of the importance back on competitions like the FA Cup and get some more variety in the teams that qualify for the Champions League.

Despite the fact that no club outside of Arsenal, Manchester United, Chelsea or Liverpool has won the competition since 1991, I actually think this is quite a nice idea. I feel that a little bit of the magic has gone out of the FA Cup in the past few years and the extra incentive of a Champions League place would make for better games. All of a sudden, moderately important FA Cup quarter-finals become vitally important for the big clubs sitting on the fringes of the third league position.

Platini's idea is a good oneCan you imagine a final where a smaller club like Aston Villa played against a bigger club like Chelsea and the prize was not only the FA Cup itself but a place in the Champions League? It would be incredibly high-pressured and unpredictable, something that cannot be said of a lot of the FA Cup finals of late, Liverpool’s remarkable win over West Ham excluded.

It is worth saying that I am a massive fan of Arsenal and would love to see them qualify for the Champions League every single season for the next one hundred years. But I also believe that giving the smaller clubs more opportunity to achieve success is vital to maintaining an entertaining and enjoyable competition. And while Arsene Wenger and even Jose Mourinho are apparently happy with the format change it seems that the boards of the top Premier League clubs are not.

A recent conference held to discuss the new proposal has led Liverpool chief executive Rick Parry to declare that the the current top four Premier League clubs as well as Newcastle United are opposed to the change for the very same reason that I am not; because it makes the competition more unpredictable.

“It’s not a question of self-interest by the big clubs. It’s just more of a lottery in the cup. There is a strong feeling the Champions League place should be based on Premier League performance.”

The only way to alter this predictable opinion is to change the system and Platini is looking to do just that. Even if it means supporters of Arsenal have to be content with watching the club play in the UEFA Cup on a more regular basis, I would love to see the format changed and the FA Cup winner be rewarded with a Champions League place.

Young Mexican Carlos Vela is set to make his debut against Brazil todayEduardo, Diarra, Gallas, Vela and Fabianski

Turning the attention to matters on the football field, a number of Arsenal players were again in action for their respective national sides overnight. Most notably, Eduardo da Silva scored his third goal in a week for Croatia as they destroyed Andorra and Lassana Diarra played a full 90 minutes at right back as France were stunned 0-1 by Scotland. Thankfully, French manager Raymond Domenech refrained from playing a not fully fit William Gallas despite recent indications that he might.

I received word from regular reader MexicanGunner that Arsenal’s young Mexican striker Carlos Vela is set to make his debut for his country in a friendly against Gilberto Silva’s Brazil today. For those that don’t know, Vela is currently on loan with Spanish club Osasuna to gain top-flight experience before returning to Arsenal for next season and is definitely one for the future. I’ll be sure to let you know how he performs.

Finally, Arsene Wenger has cleverly taken some of the focus off the Jens Lehmann-Manuel Almunia goalkeeper situation by turning his attention to current third-choice keeper Lukasz Fabianski. Wenger has mentioned that he has been impressed with Fabianski’s progress so far and dismissed suggestions that he should go out on loan to gain experience.

“I think Fabianski will be a great keeper. For me he will become the best Polish keeper. He will get his chance but he is only 22-years-old. So far I have been very, very impressed with him.”

And that is about it. Apart from this. Classic.

I’m very keen to hear your thoughts on today’s post, particularly the Champions League debate, and I encourage you to have your say by leaving a comment.

13 Responses to “FA Cup winners should get Champions League place”

  1. gunnershabz
    September 13, 2007 at 4:58 pm #

    carlos vela will be a big player for us next season, i just think wenger will not sign anymore strikers, vela has been compared to big players by his mexican coach.
    i am looking forward to seeing him in an arsenal shirt

  2. Tubes
    September 13, 2007 at 9:25 pm #

    gunnershabz,
    i´d be suprised if vela comes back to us and goes straight in to the first team, he´ll only be 17 (i think) and unless he´s as good as cesc was at that age then there´s no way.

  3. Tubes
    September 13, 2007 at 9:31 pm #

    oh and i would have to disagree with putting the winner of the F.A cup in to the CL for the simple reason that west ham very nearly won it against liverpool a couple of seasons ago and had they made it in to the CL they would of got there asses whipped. its far better having the top 4 of the PL go through as it´s based on results over a 38 game period as opposed to a flukey cup run.

  4. Spanish Fry
    September 13, 2007 at 10:10 pm #

    Tubes – That’s definitely the opinion of Parry and co and it is understandable. I definitely think that the top clubs in the league should be rewarded but I also think that giving the fourth spot to the FA Cup winner would improve the competition. As for the comment that West Ham would’ve been outplayed had they qualified, how will the smaller clubs ever improve if they are not given chances? It’s good for the game in my opinion.

  5. Tubes
    September 13, 2007 at 11:23 pm #

    but they have the transfer windows to improve their chance´s, thats what there there for. unfortuantly your always gonna have a top 4/6 in all of the major european leagues ie: in spain you have real madrid, barca, valencia seville, all of whom are gonna be there or there abouts come the end of the season.
    i agree with your point about it improving the competition but then again if you wanna push it even further why not give a CL spot to the winners of the carling cup and only have the top 2 from the PL go through. im waffling now but you get my point? i hope 🙂

  6. Spanish Fry
    September 13, 2007 at 11:26 pm #

    I understand your point but I think the FA Cup is the only one that should be rewarded. I think you’re right, you will get the same 4-6 teams but I think the current top four can virtually bank on the Champions League spot every year and spend ridiculous amounts of money accordingly. I know I am an idealist, but I would love to see the money and opportunities spread out a little more, and I see this as a great idea.

  7. Austen
    September 14, 2007 at 3:07 am #

    i agree that this youngster probably won’t be ready when he comes back if he is indeed only 17. i know that these kids can come into the league as young as 16 or w/e the age is, but you don’t see any really good or great players until they hit about 19 or 20. i.e. cesc. like theo walcott, everyone says he’ll explode this year but he’s just about 19/20. anyways, i do like the new FA Cup/CL proposal. i think EPL is dominated a little too much by the big four. any team in the league outside of the big four would find it to be a success to finish fourth. how is fourth ever a success? just my thoughts!

  8. Jay
    September 14, 2007 at 4:15 am #

    I think the FA Cup winners should go to the CL. It will make the F.A. Cup more special and who cares if a team has a flukey cup run its always good to see new teams in the CL. I am for it!

  9. Austen
    September 14, 2007 at 6:23 am #

    By the way, bacary sagna is back for spurs but no one else this including gallas

  10. Spanish Fry
    September 14, 2007 at 9:11 am #

    Austen – I saw that, more on the Arsenal-Tottenham game tomorrow.
    Jay – I feel the same way. It would good for the game in England.

  11. MexicanGunner
    September 14, 2007 at 1:57 pm #

    I like the idea of the Champions League.

  12. Uwvie
    September 14, 2007 at 5:18 pm #

    carlos vela played the last 20 minutes with strike partner giovanni dos santos. he looked lively but as expected, had trouble with the brazilian defense. i’m sure he will be vital for us. btw, he hasn’t played for osasuna yet. he’s not even on the bench yet. so he’s roughly in a similar situation as bendtner right now.

  13. darragh
    September 15, 2007 at 10:33 pm #

    Cop it Fergie!

Leave a Reply

COMMENTS POLICY

1. Think before you write.

2. Be tolerant.

3. Stay relevant.

4. If in doubt, remember Bertrand.